Skip to content
The Discord & Whiskey
Reading settings
Reading
Chapters

Chapter 1: The Girl Who Hummed

There's a bar three miles past the Whispering Galleries.

You won't see it until you're right on top of it, because it's half-buried in ash. The ash flats out there are flat and grey and dead in every direction, and the wind moves across them like it's looking for something it lost. You walk with your ears popping because the pressure is wrong there. The Black Cloud hangs two hundred feet lower over that spot than anywhere else in Kaelinor, like the sky is leaning down to listen.

And then you see it. A curve of blackened steel, warm to the touch, rising out of the ash like the rib of some great dead animal. That's the hull.

It's not a building. It's a crashed skyship called the Clear Note. A flying cathedral that fell on the Night of Severance, when the last choir of the Order of the Clear Note died in the sky.

Everyone died. Except one boy. Twelve years old.

He survived because he forgot how to sing. After the crash, he could only remember three notes. G. Eb. D. Always in that order. Always capitalized in his head. He tried to sing other notes, any other notes, and they wouldn't come. Only those three. Broken, but his.

That boy is Halven. Halven "Three-Note" now. He's sixty, but he looks thirty-eight. Time moves different inside the hull. One hour in there is one minute on the surface during Discord. That's why he lives there. That's why he sleeps there during Discord. He ages slower inside his own ship.

When he was old enough, he opened the hull as a tavern. He called it The Discord & Whiskey.

The name is simple if you know the history. The First Discord is what started the Choir Plague - the curse that kills you if you sing clean. The whiskey is what ends your night. The Sorcerer sang the wrong note once, and the world has been paying for it ever since.

It's the only tavern in the Shatter Kingdoms where singing is allowed. The hull is lined with Living Silver. That metal blocks the Plague. Outside, if you sing during Discord month, you have a 1-in-6 chance of dying on the spot. No warning. No pain. Just stopped. Inside, you won't die.

But the bar still listens. It remembers. That's the part Halven doesn't put on the sign.

Halven's rules are simple, and you learn them fast:

No singing after Stillmarch. The timbers remember.

No debts. The Silent Guilds collect for Halven. There's a whole wall - the Tally Wall - covered in chalk names. Some crossed out in blood.

If your voice cracks when you sing during Discord, you drink for free. If you hit a clean, perfect note, you're banned for life. The Plague is listening, but Halven is listening closer.

The place is small. Twelve by twenty feet. Low arched ceiling, like you're inside a buried throat. Blackened steel, still warm, sweats condensation that never drips. It just hangs there. The floor is packed ash and glass. Crunchy under your boots. Scattered with Living Silver filings - don't sweep them, that's bad luck. One lantern lights the whole place - Living Silver, hooded. Light moves like water. Throws no shadows. It makes everyone's face look strange.

When you walk in, you have to drive a nail into the bar. It's tradition. If it rings, you buy a round. If it's silent, Halven buys you one. The silent ones usually die in Discord. There's 4,017 tally marks on the beam now - one for each person who sang here and lived.

Order a " Discord," you get a double. Order a "Whiskey," and Halven pours until you tell him to stop. He won't stop on his own. Order a "Discord & Whiskey," and he slides a waiver across the bar. Paper, which is rare in there because paper rots in days from the humidity. You have to sign.

No one knew why that waiver mattered until Starfall.

On the 15th of Starfall, 65,000,016 AD, a girl walked in. Hooded. Small. Couldn't have been more than sixteen. Cloak wet with ash, boots crunching on the glass floor. She didn't look around like new people do. She didn't stare at the hull or the lantern or the tally marks. She walked straight to the bar, like she'd been there before in a dream.

She ordered a Discord & Whiskey. Her voice was hoarse, like she'd been walking for days.

Halven slid the waiver. She signed it without reading it. Her hand was steady.

And then she hummed.

Just hummed. Low. Not a song. Not even a tune, really. Just G, Eb, D, over and over, so quiet you could barely hear it under the constant low hum of the hull remembering flight.

By every law we know, by the Plague, she should have dropped dead right there. On the spot. Like everyone else who sings clean during Discord.

She didn't.

The whole tavern went quiet. The hull went quiet. Even the lantern stopped moving like water for a second.

Halven just looked at her. He didn't speak - he never speaks. He just nodded, once, and comped the drink. Poured it himself. Didn't charge.

She left a single silver coin on the bar - it rang like a bell when it hit the wood - and walked back out into the ash flats. Didn't finish the drink. Didn't say a word. Just left the coin.

Halven nailed that coin above the bottles. And it hasn't stopped humming since.

That's why the tavern is different now. On Starfall at midnight, for exactly one minute, the constant low hum of the hull goes completely silent. The coin pulses. The lantern pulses with it. And spies and rebels, scavengers and guildsmen, they all drink side by side now. No one fights. Not while she's listening.

If you ever find it, you'll know it by the smell - ozone, old whiskey, and blood-rust. Except during Glassharvest, when it smells like lightning. And the air will taste like pennies. Don't lick the walls.

Order something simple. Don't sing clean.

And if that coin above the bar is humming louder when you walk in...

Drink fast. Leave before midnight.

The hull is still warm.

That's the first thing you notice when you find it. Not the shape, not the ash half-buried up its sides, not the way the Black Cloud hangs two hundred feet lower over that one spot than anywhere else in Kaelinor. The heat.

Three days after the Clear Note fell, the ash flats should have swallowed it cold. Steel that size should be ice by then, especially out there where the wind comes off the 300-Mile Scar and cuts straight to bone. It had been three days of wind and ash and silence after the Night of Severance, when the last choir of the Order of the Clear Note died in the sky and the world lost its song.

But it wasn't cold. It was warm. Like skin.

Halven was twelve. He doesn't remember being pulled from the wreck. He remembers waking up twenty feet away, in ash up to his knees, his ears ringing so loud he thought the world had ended quiet. It had, for him.

The Clear Note had been a Resonance Hull - Diamond Nation make. Shattered cathedral meets skyship. They built them to sing. The whole hull was a throat. When the choir sang inside, the ship flew. That's why the Order of the Clear Note crewed it. Not pilots. Singers.

On the Night of Severance, 64,999,688 AD, the sky tore. Halven doesn't know what tore it. No one does. The Choir Plague wasn't a sickness then, it was an event. The First Discord. One note sung wrong, and it spread like fire in dry paper. Every choir in the Shatter Kingdoms that was singing that night died mid-note. The Clear Note fell out of the sky with a hundred throats on board.

Halven was the only one who forgot the words.

He crawled back to the hull because it was the only warm thing in a mile of cold ash. The far wall was the original hull - curved, blackened steel, still holding its arch. The rest was already starting to collapse. He pushed stone from the Scar up against it to keep the wind out. Packed ash and glass for a floor. The glass crunched under his boots. Still does, three hundred years later.

Inside, it smelled wrong. Ozone, like after lightning. Old blood, like rust. And underneath, a low hum. Not a sound, exactly. A feeling in your teeth. A vibration in the floor that you felt in your bare feet before you heard it in your ears.

He touched the wall. It was warm. It sweated. Condensation beaded on the black steel, thick as summer, but it never dripped. It just hung there. Ninety percent humidity inside, always. Paper rots in days. He learned that when he tried to write down the names of the dead and the paper went soft in his hands. That's why Halven keeps a ledger in silver ink later, not paper. Paper rots. Truth doesn't, if you carve it.

He lived there for two weeks before he realized the humming was protecting him.

On the third day, a scavenger passed the flats, singing to keep his spirits up. Old marching song. Halven watched from inside the hull. The man hit a clean note and just... stopped. Fell over. No blood. No wound. Just stopped. Like a puppet with its strings cut.

Inside, Halven had been humming the same song under his breath for an hour. Nothing happened. The same three notes, over and over. G, Eb, D.

The hull was lined with Living Silver. Filings of it were scattered across the floor - he would later learn sweeping them was bad luck, so he left them. The filings glowed faintly. The Diamond Nation had used the metal to carry sound. It turned out it could also trap it. Abjuration and Divination, mixed together. It repelled sound-based magic and recorded truth. The pressure inside was slightly high. Your ears popped when you ducked through the doorway. The Black Cloud, which hangs over all of Kaelinor, sits two hundred feet lower here than anywhere else. Like the sky is leaning in to listen.

He found the core on the fifth day. Fist-sized, embedded in the curved wall, still connected to what was left of the engine. Still warm. If you pulled it, he knew instinctively, the whole place would go cold. And the Plague would be able to walk in. That core would later be called the Humming Core. Worth 300 Guild Marks to the right buyer. But Halven never sold it. He built his whole life around it.

He found the lantern, too. One Living Silver lantern, hooded. The light inside didn't behave. It moved like water. Threw no shadows. He learned to keep it hooded low. When the Humming Coin would later appear and pulse above the bar, the lantern would pulse with it. Same rhythm. Same three notes, made of light.

That first month, the floor vibrated under his feet at night. The Black Cloud passing overhead. The air tasted like pennies. He learned not to lick the walls. Don't lick the walls. Don't lick the filings.

And he learned he could only remember three notes. G. Eb. D. Try as he might, every other note slipped out of his head like water through ash. Those three stayed. He would later make them the code for the trapdoor latch - the Dissonance Lock. Get it wrong, and it triggers an echo of the Choir Plague. Save or die. 6d10 psychic. He would tell customers it was just a lock.

He was twelve, living in a warm throat in the ash, with three notes and a hull that hummed.

He decided if he couldn't sing, he would serve those who needed to forget singing.

He drove the first nail into what would become the bar.

It rang. Clear, loud, despite the ash muffling everything else.

That was the first tally mark. Not on the beam yet - on the barrel. Later there would be 4,017 tally marks on the beam - one for each person who sang here and lived. But that first one, that first nail, that was for him. For surviving.

He was twelve. The hull was still warm. And it would stay warm for the next three hundred years, even when the rest of the world went cold. 

 

He tried to sing on the eighth day.

Halven had been mute for a week, not because he couldn't make sound, but because every time he tried, his throat closed. Trauma, he thought. Ash in his lungs. Fear. Lungs full of glass, they would call it later. Ash boy.

But on the eighth day, the wind died. The ash flats went completely still, the way they do before a Glassharvest storm. No wind, no hum from the hull. Just that high pressure that makes your ears pop. The Black Cloud had settled two hundred feet lower again, pressing down, listening.

He was alone, so he tried.

He opened his mouth to sing the lullaby his mother used to sing in the choir loft. The one that used to put the whole dormitory of choir boys to sleep. His mother, alto, two rows in front of him in the Clear Note. She had a voice that could hold a ward together by itself.

What came out was not a lullaby.

It was G. Then Eb. Then D.

Just three notes. Clean, perfect, ringing.

G - the root. Warm, like the hull. Like blackened steel, still warm, sweating condensation that never drips.

Eb - the discord. Sour, like ash in your teeth. Like pennies taste in your mouth when you breathe the flats.

D - the resolve that never resolves. Like a question that stays open.

He tried again. Different song. Same three notes. G, Eb, D. In that order. Always that order.

He tried to scream. G, Eb, D.

He tried to whisper. G, Eb, D.

He put his hand on his throat and felt the vibration. It was correct. It was his voice. But it was only those three.

He thought he was cursed. He thought the Plague had taken his tongue. He beat his fists against the warm black steel wall until his knuckles bled and the steel sweated condensation onto his blood and didn't drip. Ninety percent humidity inside, always. Paper rots in days. Blood stays. He learned that.

Later, he would understand. The Order of the Clear Note didn't just sing songs. They sang wards. Complex chords that held the ship in the air, that held the Plague out, that held truth in. The Abjuration and Divination aura that repelled sound magic and recorded truth - that was a song. A hundred voices holding one chord.

When the Night of Severance happened, when every singer who was singing died, Halven had been in the middle of a very complex phrase. His twelve-year-old brain did what brains do to survive - it cut the song off mid-word. It kept only what was directly in his mouth at the second of severance.

Three notes. The heart of a ward. The Dissonance Lock.

He didn't know that then. He just knew he was mute in every way that mattered.

If you sing a clean note in the Shatter Kingdoms during Discord, you have a 1-in-6 chance of triggering the Choir Plague and dying where you stand. Halven couldn't sing a clean note anymore. He could only sing a broken chord. And broken chords, he would learn, are invisible to the Plague. Clean notes kill. Broken notes survive.

That's why he lived when his mother died mid-note. She sang clean. He sang broken.

He spent that whole eighth day walking the perimeter of the hull, twelve by twenty feet, low arched ceiling like being inside a buried throat, dragging his hand along the warm steel. The floor was packed ash and glass, crunchy underfoot. The filings scattered across it - Living Silver filings, bad luck to sweep - shivered as he passed.

He found other things that day.

A stone from the 300-Mile Scar, half-melted into the hull. It sweats during the Hollowing, Halven would later learn. If you touch it then, you get someone else's memory. He didn't touch it that day. He just looked at it. It was weeping cold water though the hull was 70F, twelve degrees warmer than the surface.

A pile of Living Silver filings on the floor. He tried to sweep them. His hand passed through and the filings shivered and gave off a faint, discordant chime. He left them. Bad luck to sweep them, he felt. Like sweeping a grave.

And under the ash, a barrel. Intact. Stenciled with a word he couldn't read then: WHISKEY. It would become his throne. The Barrel Throne. Three notches - one for each note he can't sing.

That night, he sat on the barrel and tried to make a fourth note. Any fourth note. A, B, C, F#, anything.

Nothing. G, Eb, D.

He laughed then, and even his laugh came out as those three notes, like a broken music box.

So he stopped trying to sing. And he started to listen.

The hull hummed. Low, constant, just at the edge of hearing. If you stood very still, you could feel the floor vibrate under the packed ash and glass. Crunchy glass, from the viewport that shattered on impact. The hull was humming those same three notes. G, Eb, D. Over and over. Slow. Patient. Like it was waiting for someone to answer.

He didn't answer. He couldn't. Not yet.

He took a nail from a spar of the wreck and drove it into the barrel he was sitting on.

It rang. Clear, loud, despite the ash muffling everything else.

He decided then. If he couldn't sing, he would keep a place where others could forget how to sing, too. For a little while. For the price of a drink.

He didn't know the words for it yet, but he had just invented the first rule: Voice cracks, you drink for free. Clean note, banned for life.

Because clean notes kill. And broken notes - broken notes survive.

He was sixty now in the stories, but he looked thirty-eight. One hour inside the hull during Discord is one minute outside. Time was broken, too. Like his chord.

He had three notes. And he had a warm hull in cold ash.

It was enough to start a tavern.

The first nail rang.

Halven was twelve, ash boy, lungs full of glass, voice reduced to G, Eb, D, living in a warm throat in cold ash. Twelve by twenty, low arched ceiling, blackened steel still warm, condensation that never drips. Floor packed ash and glass, crunchy underfoot. The one Living Silver lantern, hooded, light moving like water, throwing no shadows.

He had been there nine days. Nine days of breathing ash and not dying. Nine days of the Humming Core pulsing G, Eb, D, with D failing and then holding. Nine days of the Black Cloud sitting two hundred feet lower than it should, pressure making his ears pop, air tasting like pennies.

He needed to mark time. Paper rots in days. Ninety percent humidity inside, always. He had tried to write his mother's name on a scrap. By morning it was soft and blank. The Abjuration and Divination aura records truth, but only in silver, not in paper. He needed something that wouldn't rot.

He found the nail box. In the wreckage of the Clear Note, under a spar that had been the choirmaster's podium, there was a box of nails. Iron nails, blackened, but straight. The Diamond Nation built their Resonance Hulls with iron nails that sang when you drove them. That's how they tested the hull. If the nail rang, the hull was true. If it thudded, the hull was false.

Halven took one.

He didn't know why he chose the barrel. The WHISKEY barrel that had rolled free, intact, stenciled WHISKEY. It would become the Barrel Throne, with three notches - one for each note he can't sing. But that day, it was just a barrel he was sitting on because his legs wouldn't hold him after nine days of ash.

He put the nail to the barrel and hit it with the broken-handle hammer he'd found.

It rang.

Not like a nail in wood should ring. It rang like a bell. Clear. Loud. Despite the ash muffling everything else. Despite the floor vibrating and the hull humming. It rang.

The Humming Core pulsed brighter. G, Eb, D. Stronger. D held.

He took another nail. Drove it into the blackened steel wall, where it met the stone from the 300-Mile Scar. That stone sweats during the Hollowing. If you touch it then, you get someone else's memory. He didn't know that yet. He just knew the stone was cold even though the hull was warm, twelve degrees warmer than the surface.

That second nail did not ring. It thudded. Silent nail.

He learned, right then, the rule that would become the tradition: Ringing nail marks a debt paid. Silent nail marks a debt owed.

The first nail rang, which meant the hull owed him. He had survived. The second nail was silent, which meant he owed the hull. His life. His voice. His future.

He drove nails until dusk. Some rang. Some didn't. By nightfall there were seventeen nails in the walls, in the barrel, in the floor. The tally wall had begun, though he didn't call it that yet. Later there would be 4,017 tally marks on the beam - one for each person who sang here and lived. But that first night, there were just seventeen nails, and a boy counting his own survival.

The Diamond Nation refugees watched him. They had come the day before, twelve priests in grey robes, saying the hull was their god. Now it's just warm metal and truth, Halven had told them. They didn't understand. They watched him drive nails and they thought he was mad. Ash boy, white hair that won't wash, ash that won't wash off, driving nails into a dead god.

One of them asked, "Why?"

Halven rasped, G, Eb, D, "So I know I'm here."

He drove another nail. Ringing.

He drove another. Silent.

He kept going until his hands bled and the blood mixed with the condensation that never dripped and the Living Silver filings on the floor moved away from the blood, like they were offended. Bad luck to sweep filings. Good luck to bleed on them? He didn't know. He just knew the filings shivered when blood hit them.

That night, he slept on the barrel. The WHISKEY barrel. The future Barrel Throne. He slept with the Humming Coin in his pocket pulsing against his thigh, Humming Core pulsing in the wall, the one lantern swinging though there was no wind, light moving like water.

In the morning, he counted the nails again. Seventeen. Ten ringing, seven silent. Ten debts paid, seven debts owed.

He decided, sitting on that barrel in a warm throat in cold ash, that anyone who came into his hull would have to drive a nail, too. If it rings, you buy a round. If it's silent, Halven buys you one. The silent ones usually die in Discord. That would be the rule. That would be the tradition.

He didn't know it would last three hundred years. He didn't know that on the 15th of Starfall, 65,000,016 AD, a hooded girl would drive a nail that didn't ring or thud, but hummed, and leave a silver coin that would never stop humming.

He just knew that a nail that rings means you're alive. And he was alive.

He drove one more nail, for his mother. Alto, two rows in front of him, dead mid-note on the Night of Severance.

It rang.

He kept that last nail for his mother for three hundred years.

Every night after that, when the tavern was closed and the Black Cloud pressed down low and the hull hummed its three notes, Halven would touch that nail. G, Eb, D. He never spoke her name out loud - speaking a dead singer's name during Discord is bad luck, the Plague listens for names too. He just touched the nail and let the ring fade in his ears.

The nail never rusted. Iron nails in that hull don't rust, because the Living Silver in the walls eats rust the way it eats sound. That's why the Diamond Nation built with it. That's why the filings on the floor are still bright after three hundred years. He learned not to sweep them. Bad luck to sweep them. Good luck to bleed on them? He never figured that one out.

That morning, he carved his first rule into the barrel with the nail tip: Ringing nail marks a debt paid. Silent nail marks a debt owed. He couldn't write much - his hands were shaking, ash in his lungs, glass in his boots - but he carved that one line, and it stayed. Later, the Tally Wall would be covered in chalk names, some crossed out in blood. The Silent Guilds would collect for Halven. The rules would grow. No singing after Stillmarch. No debts. Voice cracks, you drink for free. Clean note, banned for life. All of that came later.

But it started with one nail that rang.

Halven didn't write the rules. The rules wrote themselves in blood.

The first winter after the Clear Note fell, he learned that warm metal and truth attract people. The ash flats are not empty. They are full of people walking away from something. Scavengers. Guildsmen. Spies. Rebels. Priests in grey robes who said the hull was their god. They all found the warm throat in the cold ash, because warm is a beacon when everything else is cold.

Halven was twelve. He was not a barkeep. He was a boy with three notes and a barrel. He didn't want company. He wanted quiet, because quiet meant the Plague wasn't listening.

But they kept coming. And they kept singing.

The first man who sang clean inside the hull died on the spot. Not outside, where the 1-in-6 chance is a story you tell around fires. Inside. Halven had thought the Living Silver lining would protect everyone. It did protect the hull. It did not protect the man who sang a perfect, clean, beautiful note right in front of the Humming Core.

The man fell. No blood. No wound. Just stopped. Like a puppet with its strings cut. Halven dragged him out into the ash and left him for the wind. He didn't have a shovel. He didn't have a grave. He had a nail.

He drove a nail into the Tally Wall for that man. Silent nail. Debt owed.

The second man who sang inside cracked his voice. It broke halfway through, G, Eb, D, broken, ugly, honest. He lived. Halven gave him a drink for free. He didn't know why, but his hands did it before his brain could argue. Voice cracks, you drink for free. That was the first rule, and it came from blood, not from a book.

The third man sang after Stillmarch. Halven didn't know what Stillmarch was then. He just knew that after midnight, the timbers remembered. The hull's hum changed after midnight, low, patient, like it was listening harder. That man sang after midnight, and the timbers remembered his voice, and the next night the hull hummed his song back to him, and he went mad. He ran out into the ash flats screaming his own name. Halven never saw him again.

No singing after Stillmarch. The timbers remember. That was the second rule.

The fourth man owed a debt. He drank, he sang, he promised to pay tomorrow. Tomorrow came. He didn't pay. He came back the next night and drank again. Halven was twelve, ash boy, white hair that won't wash, and he had no way to make a grown man pay. So he told the Silent Guilds. They collect for Halven now. There's a whole wall - the Tally Wall - covered in chalk names. Some crossed out in blood. That's what happens when you don't pay. No debts. That was the third rule.

The fifth man hit a clean, perfect note. Not a broken chord. Not a crack. A perfect note, held, beautiful, like the Order of the Clear Note used to sing. The lantern flickered. The Humming Core pulsed, D failing and then holding. The whole hull went quiet for one second, like the Black Cloud pressing down two hundred feet lower, listening.

Halven banned him for life. He didn't know the words for it then. He just pointed at the door and said, G, Eb, D, which meant out. The man left. He never came back. If you hit a clean, perfect note, you're banned for life. That was the fourth rule.

Halven carved them into the barrel with a nail tip. Not on paper - paper rots in days, ninety percent humidity inside, always. On the barrel. On the wall. On the beam where there would later be 4,017 tally marks - one for each person who sang here and lived.

No singing after Stillmarch. The timbers remember.

No debts. The Silent Guilds collect for Halven.

If your voice cracks when you sing during Discord, you drink for free. If you hit a clean, perfect note, you're banned for life.

He didn't write them to be clever. He wrote them because people died when he didn't.

Later, when the tavern was real, when Halven was sixty but looked thirty-eight because one hour inside during Discord is one minute outside, he added the waiver. Order a " Discord," you get a double. Order a "Whiskey," and Halven pours until you tell him to stop. Order a " Discord & Whiskey," and he slides a waiver across the bar. Paper, which is rare because paper rots in days. You have to sign.

No one knew why that waiver mattered until Starfall.

On the 15th of Starfall, 65,000,016 AD, a hooded girl walked in, sixteen, cloak wet with ash, boots crunching on glass, ordered a Discord & Whiskey, signed the waiver without reading it, and hummed. Just hummed. G, Eb, D. Low. By every law we know, she should have dropped dead. She didn't.

Halven comped the drink. She left a silver coin that rang like a bell. He nailed it above the bottles. It hasn't stopped humming since.

That's why the rules matter. They are not rules. They are the shape of survival. The hull is still warm. The coin is still humming. The Black Cloud is still listening.

If you ever find it, you'll know it by the smell - ozone, old whiskey, and blood-rust. Except during Glassharvest, when it smells like lightning. And the air will taste like pennies.

Order something simple. Don't sing clean.

And if you sign the waiver...

Read it first. Halven didn't. The girl didn't. You should.

Drink fast. Leave before midnight. Because at midnight on Starfall, for exactly one minute, the hum stops. The coin pulses. And everyone in the tavern - spies and rebels, scavengers and guildsmen - they all drink side by side. No one fights. Not while she's listening.

That's Chapter 1. That's how the tavern was born. Not from a plan. From nails and blood and three notes that wouldn't die.

Sign in to likeSign in to bookmark
6 views · 5294 words

Discuss this chapter

Please Login in order to comment!